Ron Baker – The Subscription Model for Service Providers
Below is a comprehensive, structured summary of the main themes and points covered by Ron Baker in the transcript on strategy and positioning for professional firms, focusing especially on the transition from traditional billing models to the subscription business model.
Context and Background
- Ron Baker’s journey began in the late 1980s when he left a Big Eight accounting firm to start his own practice and experiment with fixed pricing instead of billing by the hour. At that time, resources on alternative pricing methods were virtually nonexistent. Yet, the shift away from hourly billing improved the customer experience and overall client relationships.
- Over time, Baker has evolved his stance from simply using fixed prices and value pricing to embracing a new model: subscription-based pricing, which he believes better aligns with the professional’s purpose.
Professionals and Their Purpose
- The foundational question: “Why did you enter the accounting profession?” Most respond with “to help people.” This motivation aligns more naturally with a subscription model that focuses on relationship-building and guiding clients to their desired outcomes—ultimately helping them become “healthier, wealthier, and wiser.”
- Baker emphasizes that accounting, bookkeeping, and advisory professionals occupy a privileged position to truly improve their customers’ lives and businesses, not just provide a series of compliance tasks.
Defining the Subscription Business Model
- Subscription Model Concept: A periodic recurring payment (usually monthly, but can be weekly, quarterly, or annually) for frictionless, ever-increasing value. Key elements:
- Periodic Recurring Payment: Regular billing cycles, rather than one-time or ad-hoc fees.
- Frictionless: Customers make one pricing decision at the outset and no longer face hurdles like annual fee changes, scope adjustments, or complex re-pricing exercises.
- Ever-Increasing Value (“Plussing”): Continuous innovation and adding new features or benefits over time to surprise and delight subscribers, much like Disney’s concept of “plussing.”
- In this model, customers subscribe to the firm itself, not discrete services. Unlike value pricing, where scope, change orders, and negotiations persist, a true subscription aims to eliminate such friction.
Implications for Accounting and Measurement
- Subscription vs. Traditional Income Statement:
- Traditional: Driven by units sold (services, hours, tasks).
- Subscription: Focused on Annual (or Monthly) Recurring Revenue (ARR/MRR), churn rate (lost subscribers), and an ongoing relationship rather than one-off sales of services.
- Key Performance Indicators (KPIs):
- Churn rate (percentage of customers lost over a period).
- Annual/Monthly Recurring Revenue (ARR/MRR).
- Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) and Customer Lifetime Value (LTV).
- Understanding these KPIs is crucial in a subscription world, as they measure relationship and value over time rather than short-term profit per job or per hour.
- No More Timesheets:
- The subscription model obviates the need for tracking time because the focus shifts from inputs and hours to outcomes and relationships. Performance and profitability are assessed at the portfolio level rather than per project or per hour.
The Economic Progression to Transformations
- Baker references the work of Pine and Gilmore in “The Experience Economy” (1999), which identifies a progression of economic value from commodities → goods → services → experiences → transformations.
- Transformations as Highest Value: Professionals can guide clients to a desired future state (e.g., improving their business, achieving financial goals, planning legacies). Transformational outcomes have greater pricing power and relevance than delivering mere services.
- Subscription models align with delivering transformations, as ongoing relationships and continuous improvement are integral to guiding clients through multiple transformative stages over their lifetime.
Practical Example: Landscaping Services
- Three landscapers approach a property:
- Hourly billing at $40/hour (input-based, limited pricing power).
- Fixed monthly fee of $120 for defined services (limited scope, minor improvement over hourly but still constrained).
- Subscription offering packages: Basic maintenance, neighborhood standard, or best curbside appeal with ongoing improvements.
- The third landscaper commands significantly higher fees (e.g., $350/month) by focusing on a desired result (transformation in the property’s appearance) rather than just service delivery.
A Model Profession Already Doing This: Direct Primary Care (DPC) Doctors
- DPC physicians charge a periodic fee for comprehensive primary care services, placing no restrictions on office visits or communication. This frictionless model builds extraordinary relationships, improves patient outcomes, and aligns perfectly with the doctor’s purpose of helping people, rather than billing per visit or treatment.
Benefits of the Subscription Model
- Purpose-Led vs. Profit-Led: The business aligns with helping and impacting clients rather than merely generating fees.
- Relationship-Focused: Strong, long-term bonds with a smaller number of customers, creating deeper loyalty and trust.
- Less Burnout, More Moral Fulfillment: Professionals can practice as they intended, focusing on client transformations rather than compliance and billing metrics. It reduces “moral injury” and keeps professionals aligned with their true calling.
- Enhanced Firm Value: True recurring revenue with established churn rates increases a firm’s market value—potentially 5-7 times (or more) revenue multiples compared to traditional firms.
- Pricing Power and Differentiation: Presenting an uncommon offering commands uncommon prices, distinguishing a subscription firm from traditional competitors.
Cultural and Linguistic Shifts
- The language used matters.
- Move from “billing for services” to focusing on “customer success,” “members,” “transformations,” and “colleagues.”
- Shift from “scope of work” to “guiding transformations.”
- This linguistic change fosters a new mindset and culture within the firm, supporting purpose-driven relationships and continuous improvement.
The Innovation Curve and Early Adopters
- Baker acknowledges this is a radical shift, appealing first to innovators and early adopters (around 2.5% to 16% of the market).
- He believes that bookkeepers and smaller, more entrepreneurial firms may be the first to embrace this model, leveraging their closer relationships with fewer clients.
- As with value pricing before it, subscription-based transformation will eventually diffuse through the industry, but early adopters will reap the most substantial competitive advantages and pricing power.
Resources Provided
- Baker suggests several foundational books on subscription economics (Tien Tzuo’s “Subscribed,” John Warrillow’s “The Automatic Customer,” and others).
- He also references two Andreessen Horowitz reports on KPIs for subscription models and his radio show, “The Soul of Enterprise,” where he’s interviewed leading thinkers in the space.
Conclusion
Ron Baker’s presentation encourages firms to reevaluate their business model from selling hours and services to offering outcomes, relationships, and transformations through a subscription-based approach. This approach:
- Realigns the professional’s purpose with their daily practice.
- Increases pricing power and firm value.
- Fosters stronger, lifelong relationships with clients.
- Frees professionals from timesheets and scope creep, allowing them to focus on innovation, emotional capacity, and true client impact.
Ultimately, Baker posits that the subscription model is the future direction for professional firms committed to making a tangible, transformational difference for their clients.